Third national assessment
- Executive Summary
- 1.0 Introduction
- 2.0 Methods
- 3.0 Presence or Absence of Effects
- 4.0 Effluent Quality
- 5.0 Biological Monitoring Studies Investigating Observed Effects
- 6.0 Key Findings
- 7.0 Glossary
- 8.0 References
- Appendix A: Metal Mines Subject to the Metal Mining Effluent Regulations in 2013
- Appendix B: Effect Indicators, Critical Effects Sizes and Studies Conducted
- Appendix C: Mine-by-Mine Results of Studies Assessing Potential Effects
- Appendix D: Fish Tissue Mean Total Mercury Concentrations per Mine
- Appendix E: Trends in Sublethal Toxicity
- Appendix F: Trends in Sublethal Toxicity for Ore Types
- Appendix G: Annual Mean Concentrations of Effluent Characterization Data
- Appendix H: Mine-by-Mine Summary of Investigation Studies
Appendix C: Mine-by-Mine Results of Studies Assessing Potential Effects
Table C1. Mine-by-mine results of studies assessing potential effects on fish and fish habitat
Effect for Fish Habitat
- Base Metal Mines (includes copper, nickel, lead, zinc and molybdenum)
- Iron Ore Mines (includes iron and titanium)
- Precious Metals Mines (includes gold, silver and platinum group metals)
- Uranium Mines
- Other Metal Mines (includes tungsten, tantalum, niobium and magnesium)
Effect for Fish and Highest Level of Effect
- Base Metal Mines (includes copper, nickel, lead, zinc and molybdenum)
- Iron Ore Mines (includes iron and titanium)
- Precious Metals Mines (includes gold, silver and platinum group metals)
- Uranium Mines
- Other Metal Mines (includes tungsten, tantalum, niobium and magnesium)
effect ≥ critical effect size (CES) | effect observed in one study of a magnitude ≥ CES |
effect< CES | effect observed in one study of a magnitude< CES |
effect of unknown magnitude | effect observed in one study of undetermined magnitude |
absence of effect | effect not observed in one study |
confirmed ≥ CES | similar type of effect observed in two consecutive studies of a magnitude ≥ CES |
confirmed variable magnitude | similar type of effect observed in two consecutive studies of a magnitude ≥ CES in one study and< CES in the other study |
confirmed< CES | similar type of effect observed in two consecutive studies of a magnitude< CES |
confirmed unknown magnitude | similar type of effect observed in two consecutive studies of undetermined magnitude |
confirmed absence of effect | effect not observed in two consecutive studies |
unconfirmed effect | effect observed in one study and not observed in the other study |
(<) | effect or confirmed effect where effect indicator is smaller in the exposure area relative to the reference area |
(>) | effect or confirmed effect where effect indicator is larger in the exposure area relative to the reference area |
na | sufficient data to assess effect was not available |
Effect for Fish Habitat
Highest Level of Effect for Fish Habitat | Density | Taxon Richness | Similarity Index | Evenness Index | |
BM1 | confirmed variable magnitude | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed variable magnitude | unconfirmed effect |
BM2 | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed ≥ CES | unconfirmed effect |
BM3 | confirmed ≥ CES | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES (<) | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed absence of effect |
BM4 | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed ≥ CES (<) | confirmed ≥ CES | unconfirmed effect |
BM5 | confirmed ≥ CES | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES (<) | unconfirmed effect | na |
BM6 | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | na |
BM7 | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed absence of effect |
BM8 | absence of effect | absence of effect | absence of effect | absence of effect | absence of effect |
BM9 | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed ≥ CES (>) | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed< CES | na |
BM10 | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed variable magnitude (<) | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect |
BM11 | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed ≥ CES (>) | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | na |
BM12 | effect< CES | absence of effect | absence of effect | < CES | < CES (<) |
BM13 | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect |
BM14 | confirmed ≥ CES | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES (<) | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed variable magnitude (<) |
BM15 | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect |
BM16 | confirmed ≥ CES | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES (<) | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed ≥ CES (>) |
BM17 | confirmed variable magnitude | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed variable magnitude | unconfirmed effect |
BM18 | confirmed variable magnitude | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed variable magnitude | unconfirmed effect |
BM19 | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed ≥ CES (<) |
BM20 | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed ≥ CES (>) | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed< CES | unconfirmed effect |
BM21 | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect |
BM22 | confirmed variable magnitude | confirmed absence of effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed variable magnitude | unconfirmed effect |
BM23 | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect |
BM24 | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect |
BM25 | confirmed variable magnitude | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed variable magnitude | unconfirmed effect |
BM26 | effect< CES | < CES (<) | absence of effect | absence of effect | absence of effect |
BM27 | confirmed ≥ CES | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed ≥ CES | unconfirmed effect |
BM28 | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect |
BM29 | effect ≥ CES | < CES (>) | ≥ CES (<) | ≥ CES | ≥ CES (<) |
BM30 | confirmed variable magnitude | confirmed variable magnitude (>) | confirmed< CES (>) | confirmed variable magnitude | unconfirmed effect |
BM31 | effect< CES | < CES (<) | absence of effect | absence of effect | absence of effect |
BM32 | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed ≥ CES (>) | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed ≥ CES | unconfirmed effect |
BM33 | confirmed variable magnitude | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed variable magnitude | confirmed absence of effect |
BM34 | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect |
BM35 | effect ≥ CES | ≥ CES (<) | < CES (<) | ≥ CES | absence of effect |
BM36 | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect |
BM37 | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect |
BM38 | effect ≥ CES | absence of effect | absence of effect | ≥ CES | ≥ CES (>) |
BM39 | confirmed ≥ CES | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed absence of effect |
BM40 | effect ≥ CES | ≥ CES (>) | absence of effect | ≥ CES | absence of effect |
BM41 | effect ≥ CES | ≥ CES (<) | < CES (>) | ≥ CES | absence of effect |
BM42 | effect ≥ CES | < CES (<) | < CES (<) | ≥ CES | absence of effect |
BM43 | confirmed ≥ CES | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed absence of effect |
BM44 | absence of effect | absence of effect | absence of effect | absence of effect | absence of effect |
BM45 | effect of unknown magnitude | effect of unknown magnitude (<) | effect of unknown magnitude (<) | effect of unknown magnitude |
Highest Level of Effect for Fish Habitat | Density | Taxon Richness | Similarity Index | Evenness Index | |
FeTi1 | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed ≥ CES (<) | confirmed ≥ CES (<) | confirmed ≥ CES | unconfirmed effect |
FeTi2 | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed absence of effect |
FeTi3 | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect |
FeTi4 | effect ≥ CES | absence of effect | absence of effect | ≥ CES | absence of effect |
FeTi5 | confirmed variable magnitude | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed variable magnitude (<) | confirmed< CES | confirmed absence of effect |
FeTi6 | effect ≥ CES | absence of effect | < CES (<) | ≥ CES | absence of effect |
FeTi7 | absence of effect | absence of effect | absence of effect | absence of effect | absence of effect |
Highest Level of Effect for Fish Habitat | Density | Taxon Richness | Similarity Index | Evenness Index | |
PM1 | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed absence of effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed ≥ CES (>) |
PM2 | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed variable magnitude (<) | confirmed ≥ CES (<) | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect |
PM3 | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect |
PM4 | confirmed ≥ CES | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed absence of effect |
PM5 | confirmed< CES | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed< CES (>) |
PM6 | effect ≥ CES | ≥ CES (<) | absence of effect | < CES | absence of effect |
PM7 | confirmed ≥ CES | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES | unconfirmed effect |
PM8 | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect |
PM9 | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect |
PM10 | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect |
PM11 | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed variable magnitude (<) | confirmed ≥ CES (<) | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect |
PM12 | effect ≥ CES | absence of effect | absence of effect | ≥ CES | absence of effect |
PM13 | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed ≥ CES (>) | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed ≥ CES (<) |
PM14 | confirmed variable magnitude | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed variable magnitude | unconfirmed effect |
PM15 | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect |
PM16 | confirmed ≥ CES | unconfirmed effect | confirmed variable magnitude (<) | confirmed ≥ CES | unconfirmed effect |
PM17 | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | unconfirmed effect |
PM18 | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect |
PM19 | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect |
PM20 | confirmed variable magnitude | unconfirmed effect | confirmed variable magnitude (>) | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect |
PM21 | confirmed variable magnitude | confirmed variable magnitude (>) | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed variable magnitude | unconfirmed effect |
PM22 | effect ≥ CES | ≥ CES (<) | absence of effect | absence of effect | absence of effect |
PM23 | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect |
PM24 | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect | unconfirmed effect |
PM25 | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect |
PM26 | confirmed variable magnitude | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed variable magnitude | unconfirmed effect |
PM27 | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect | unconfirmed effect |
PM28 | confirmed ≥ CES | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES (<) | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed ≥ CES (>) |
PM29 | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect |
PM30 | effect ≥ CES | absence of effect | absence of effect | ≥ CES | absence of effect |
PM31 | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect |
PM32 | confirmed variable magnitude | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed variable magnitude (<) | confirmed variable magnitude | unconfirmed effect |
PM33 | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed absence of effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed absence of effect |
PM34 | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect |
PM35 | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed ≥ CES (>) | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed absence of effect |
PM36 | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed ≥ CES (<) | confirmed ≥ CES (<) | confirmed variable magnitude | confirmed absence of effect |
PM37 | effect ≥ CES | < CES (<) | absence of effect | ≥ CES | ≥ CES (>) |
PM38 | effect ≥ CES | absence of effect | absence of effect | ≥ CES | absence of effect |
PM39 | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect |
PM40 | effect ≥ CES | ≥ CES (>) | absence of effect | ≥ CES | < CES (<) |
PM41 | confirmed ≥ CES | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed ≥ CES | unconfirmed effect |
PM42 | effect ≥ CES | absence of effect | absence of effect | ≥ CES | absence of effect |
PM43 | effect ≥ CES | absence of effect | absence of effect | ≥ CES | < CES (>) |
PM44 | effect< CES | absence of effect | < CES (<) | absence of effect | absence of effect |
PM45 | absence of effect | absence of effect | absence of effect | absence of effect | absence of effect |
PM46 | confirmed ≥ CES | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed absence of effect |
PM47 | effect ≥ CES | ≥ CES (<) | ≥ CES (<) | ≥ CES | absence of effect |
PM48 | effect ≥ CES | absence of effect | absence of effect | ≥ CES | absence of effect |
PM49 | effect ≥ CES | ≥ CES (>) | absence of effect | ≥ CES | ≥ CES (<) |
PM50 | effect< CES | < CES (<) | absence of effect | < CES | absence of effect |
PM51 | absence of effect | absence of effect | absence of effect | absence of effect | absence of effect |
PM52 | absence of effect | absence of effect | absence of effect | absence of effect | absence of effect |
PM53 | effect< CES | < CES (>) | absence of effect | < CES | < CES (<) |
Highest Level of Effect for Fish Habitat | Density | Taxon Richness | Similarity Index | Evenness Index | |
U1 | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed ≥ CES (<) | confirmed ≥ CES (<) | confirmed ≥ CES | unconfirmed effect |
U2 | confirmed ≥ CES | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed absence of effect |
U3 | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed ≥ CES (>) | confirmed< CES (>) | confirmed variable magnitude | unconfirmed effect |
U4 | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect |
U5 | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed ≥ CES (>) | confirmed variable magnitude (>) | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed absence of effect |
U6 | effect ≥ CES | ≥ CES (<) | ≥ CES (<) | ≥ CES | ≥ CES (>) |
Highest Level of Effect for Fish Habitat | Density | Taxon Richness | Similarity Index | Evenness Index | |
O1 | confirmed ≥ CES | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed variable magnitude | confirmed ≥ CES (>) |
O2 | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect |
O3 | confirmed ≥ CES | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES (<) | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed ≥ CES (<) |
O4 | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed ≥ CES (>) | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed absence of effect |
Effect for Fish and Highest Level of Effect
Highest Level of Effect for Fish | Survival | Growth | Reproduction | Body Condition | Liver Condition | Highest Level of Effect for Fish and Fish Habitat | |
BM1 | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed variable magnitude (<) | confirmed variable magnitude (>) | confirmed variable magnitude (>) | confirmed variable magnitude (>) | confirmed ≥ CES (>) | confirmed ≥ CES |
BM2 | unconfirmed effect | na | na | na | unconfirmed effect | na | confirmed ≥ CES |
BM3 | confirmed unknown magnitude | confirmed unknown magnitude (<) | confirmed unknown magnitude (>) | na | unconfirmed effect | na | confirmed ≥ CES |
BM4 | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed variable magnitude (>) | confirmed< CES (>) | confirmed ≥ CES (<) | confirmed variable magnitude (>) | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES |
BM5 | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | na | confirmed absence of effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed ≥ CES |
BM6 | effect ≥ CES | absence of effect | na | absence of effect | ≥ CES (>) | absence of effect | effect ≥ CES |
BM7 | confirmed variable magnitude | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed variable magnitude (<) | confirmed ≥ CES |
BM8 | effect of unknown magnitude | absence of effect | effect of unknown magnitude (>) | na | effect of unknown magnitude (>) | na | effect of unknown magnitude |
BM9 | confirmed unknown magnitude | na | confirmed unknown magnitude (>) | na | confirmed absence of effect | na | confirmed ≥ CES |
BM10 | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed< CES (>) | confirmed ≥ CES (<) | confirmed< CES (<) | confirmed ≥ CES (<) | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES |
BM11 | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | na | confirmed absence of effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed ≥ CES |
BM12 | no result: study not required | no result: study not required | no result: study not required | no result: study not required | no result: study not required | no result: study not required | effect< CES |
BM13 | confirmed ≥ CES | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed variable magnitude (>) | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES (>) | confirmed ≥ CES |
BM14 | confirmed< CES | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed< CES (<) | confirmed< CES (<) | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES |
BM15 | effect of unknown magnitude | effect of unknown magnitude (>) | effect of unknown magnitude (>) | effect of unknown magnitude (<) | effect of unknown magnitude (>) | na | unconfirmed effect |
BM16 | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | na | na | unconfirmed effect | na | confirmed ≥ CES |
BM17 | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed variable magnitude |
BM18 | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | unconfirmed effect | na | confirmed variable magnitude |
BM19 | confirmed unknown magnitude | confirmed unknown magnitude (>) | unconfirmed effect | na | unconfirmed effect | na | confirmed ≥ CES |
BM20 | unconfirmed effect | na | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed ≥ CES |
BM21 | confirmed< CES | na | na | na | confirmed< CES (>) | na | confirmed< CES |
BM22 | confirmed unknown magnitude | na | na | na | confirmed unknown magnitude (>) | na | confirmed variable magnitude |
BM23 | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed absence of effect | unconfirmed effect |
BM24 | confirmed unknown magnitude | confirmed unknown magnitude (<) | na | na | unconfirmed effect | na | confirmed unknown magnitude |
BM25 | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed variable magnitude |
BM26 | effect ≥ CES | ≥ CES (<) | na | na | na | na | effect ≥ CES |
BM27 | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed< CES (>) | confirmed ≥ CES (<) | confirmed< CES (<) | confirmed ≥ CES (<) | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES |
BM28 | no result: fish survey could not be conducted or completed | no result: fish survey could not be conducted or completed | no result: fish survey could not be conducted or completed | no result: fish survey could not be conducted or completed | no result: fish survey could not be conducted or completed | no result: fish survey could not be conducted or completed | unconfirmed effect |
BM29 | effect ≥ CES | absence of effect | ≥ CES (>) | effect of unknown magnitude (>) | effect of unknown magnitude (>) | ≥ CES (>) | effect ≥ CES |
BM30 | confirmed unknown magnitude | confirmed unknown magnitude (>) | confirmed unknown magnitude (>) | na | unconfirmed effect | na | confirmed variable magnitude |
BM31 | effect< CES | na | na | absence of effect | < CES (<) | absence of effect | effect< CES |
BM32 | effect< CES | absence of effect | effect of unknown magnitude (>) | na | < CES (>) | na | confirmed ≥ CES |
BM33 | confirmed< CES | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed< CES (>) | confirmed< CES (>) | confirmed variable magnitude |
BM34 | confirmed absence of effect | na | na | na | confirmed absence of effect | na | unconfirmed effect |
BM35 | no result: study not required | no result: study not required | no result: study not required | no result: study not required | no result: study not required | no result: study not required | effect ≥ CES |
BM36 | confirmed ≥ CES | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES (>) | confirmed ≥ CES (>) | confirmed ≥ CES (>) | confirmed ≥ CES |
BM37 | confirmed absence of effect | na | na | na | confirmed absence of effect | na | confirmed absence of effect |
BM38 | no result: study not required | no result: study not required | no result: study not required | no result: study not required | no result: study not required | no result: study not required | effect ≥ CES |
BM39 | confirmed variable magnitude | na | na | confirmed variable magnitude (<) | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES |
BM40 | effect< CES | na | na | absence of effect | < CES (<) | absence of effect | effect ≥ CES |
BM41 | no result: fish survey could not be conducted or completed | no result: fish survey could not be conducted or completed | no result: fish survey could not be conducted or completed | no result: fish survey could not be conducted or completed | no result: fish survey could not be conducted or completed | no result: fish survey could not be conducted or completed | effect ≥ CES |
BM42 | effect ≥ CES | < CES (<) | ≥ CES (<) | ≥ CES (<) | < CES (>) | < CES (>) | effect ≥ CES |
BM43 | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES |
BM44 | effect< CES | na | na | na | < CES (<) | na | effect< CES |
BM45 | effect of unknown magnitude | absence of effect | effect of unknown magnitude (>) | absence of effect | absence of effect | effect of unknown magnitude (>) | effect of unknown magnitude |
Highest Level of Effect for Fish | Survival | Growth | Reproduction | Body Condition | Liver Condition | Highest Level of Effect for Fish and Fish Habitat | |
FeTi1 | confirmed ≥ CES | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES (<) | confirmed variable magnitude (<) | confirmed ≥ CES (<) | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES |
FeTi2 | confirmed < CES | unconfirmed effect | confirmed < CES (<) | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES |
FeTi3 | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | na | na | unconfirmed effect | na | unconfirmed effect |
FeTi4 | effect of unknown magnitude | absence of effect | absence of effect | absence of effect | absence of effect | effect of unknown magnitude (<) | effect ≥ CES |
FeTi5 | confirmed variable magnitude | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed variable magnitude (<) | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed variable magnitude |
FeTi6 | no result: fish survey could not be conducted or completed | no result: fish survey could not be conducted or completed | no result: fish survey could not be conducted or completed | no result: fish survey could not be conducted or completed | no result: fish survey could not be conducted or completed | no result: fish survey could not be conducted or completed | effect ≥ CES |
FeTi7 | effect ≥ CES | ≥ CES (>) | effect of unknown magnitude (>) | effect of unknown magnitude (<) | effect of unknown magnitude (<) | effect of unknown magnitude (<) | effect ≥ CES |
Highest Level of Effect for Fish | Survival | Growth | Reproduction | Body Condition | Liver Condition | Highest Level of Effect for Fish and Fish Habitat | |
PM1 | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed variable magnitude (<) | confirmed ≥ CES (>) | unconfirmed effect | confirmed < CES (<) | confirmed variable magnitude (>) | confirmed ≥ CES |
PM2 | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed ≥ CES (>) | unconfirmed effect | confirmed variable magnitude (<) | confirmed ≥ CES (<) | confirmed ≥ CES (<) | confirmed ≥ CES |
PM3 | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed absence of effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES (>) | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES (>) | confirmed ≥ CES |
PM4 | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES |
PM5 | effect ≥ CES | ≥ CES (<) | ≥ CES (>) | ≥ CES (>) | < CES (>) | ≥ CES (>) | confirmed < CES |
PM6 | effect ≥ CES | effect of unknown magnitude (>) | na | na | ≥ CES (>) | < CES (<) | effect ≥ CES |
PM7 | confirmed < CES | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed < CES (>) | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES |
PM8 | effect of unknown magnitude | effect of unknown magnitude (>) | absence of effect | absence of effect | effect of unknown magnitude (<) | effect of unknown magnitude (>) | unconfirmed effect |
PM9 | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | na | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect |
PM10 | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | na | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect |
PM11 | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed ≥ CES (>) | confirmed variable magnitude (<) | confirmed variable magnitude (<) | confirmed ≥ CES (<) | confirmed ≥ CES (<) | confirmed ≥ CES |
PM12 | effect < CES | < CES (<) | absence of effect | absence of effect | absence of effect | absence of effect | effect ≥ CES |
PM13 | confirmed < CES | unconfirmed effect | confirmed < CES (<) | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES |
PM14 | confirmed < CES | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed < CES (<) | confirmed < CES (<) | unconfirmed effect | confirmed variable magnitude |
PM15 | effect of unknown magnitude | effect of unknown magnitude (>) | effect of unknown magnitude (>) | na | effect of unknown magnitude (<) | na | unconfirmed effect |
PM16 | confirmed variable magnitude | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed variable magnitude (>) | confirmed ≥ CES |
PM17 | effect < CES | absence of effect | absence of effect | absence of effect | absence of effect | < CES (<) | unconfirmed effect |
PM18 | unconfirmed effect | na | na | na | unconfirmed effect | na | unconfirmed effect |
PM19 | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | na | unconfirmed effect |
PM20 | effect of unknown magnitude | absence of effect | effect of unknown magnitude (<) | na | effect of unknown magnitude (<) | na | confirmed variable magnitude |
PM21 | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed variable magnitude (<) | confirmed ≥ CES (>) | unconfirmed effect | confirmed < CES (>) | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES |
PM22 | effect ≥ CES | absence of effect | < CES (<) | absence of effect | absence of effect | ≥ CES (>) | effect ≥ CES |
PM23 | effect of unknown magnitude | effect of unknown magnitude (<) | absence of effect | absence of effect | effect of unknown magnitude (>) | na | unconfirmed effect |
PM24 | effect ≥ CES | ≥ CES (>) | < CES (t;) | < CES (<) | ≥ CES (t;) | ≥ CES (<) | unconfirmed effect |
PM25 | confirmed < CES | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed < CES (<) | unconfirmed effect | confirmed < CES |
PM26 | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed ≥ CES (<) | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed ≥ CES (<) | confirmed ≥ CES (<) | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES |
PM27 | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect |
PM28 | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed ≥ CES (>) | confirmed ≥ CES (>) | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES |
PM29 | confirmed variable magnitude | na | na | na | confirmed variable magnitude (<) | na | confirmed variable magnitude |
PM30 | confirmed < CES | confirmed absence of effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed < CES (<) | unconfirmed effect | confirmed < CES |
PM31 | confirmed variable magnitude | unconfirmed effect | confirmed unknown magnitude (<) | confirmed variable magnitude (>) | confirmed unknown magnitude (<) | unconfirmed effect | confirmed variable magnitude |
PM32 | confirmed variable magnitude | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed variable magnitude (>) | unconfirmed effect | confirmed variable magnitude |
PM33 | no result: fish survey could not be conducted or completed | no result: fish survey could not be conducted or completed | no result: fish survey could not be conducted or completed | no result: fish survey could not be conducted or completed | no result: fish survey could not be conducted or completed | no result: fish survey could not be conducted or completed | confirmed ≥ CES |
PM34 | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | na | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect |
PM35 | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed < CES (>) | confirmed unknown magnitude (<) | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES (<) | confirmed variable magnitude (<) | confirmed ≥ CES |
PM36 | confirmed unknown magnitude | confirmed unknown magnitude (>) | confirmed unknown magnitude (<) | na | confirmed unknown magnitude (<) | na | confirmed ≥ CES |
PM37 | absence of effect | absence of effect | absence of effect | absence of effect | absence of effect | absence of effect | effect ≥ CES |
PM38 | effect ≥ CES | < CES (<) | absence of effect | ≥ CES (<) | absence of effect | ≥ CES (<) | effect ≥ CES |
PM39 | no result: study not required | no result: study not required | no result: study not required | no result: study not required | no result: study not required | no result: study not required | unconfirmed effect |
PM40 | effect ≥ CES | < CES (>) | ≥ CES (<) | < CES (<) | ≥ CES (>) | ≥ CES (>) | effect ≥ CES |
PM41 | confirmed ≥ CES | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES (>) | confirmed variable magnitude (>) | confirmed < CES (>) | confirmed < CES (>) | confirmed ≥ CES |
PM42 | effect ≥ CES | absence of effect | ≥ CES (>) | absence of effect | ≥ CES (>) | < CES (>) | effect ≥ CES |
PM43 | effect of unknown magnitude | na | na | na | effect of unknown magnitude (>) | na | effect ≥ CES |
PM44 | effect ≥ CES | effect of unknown magnitude (>) | effect of unknown magnitude (>) | absence of effect | ≥ CES (>) | na | effect ≥ CES |
PM45 | absence of effect | absence of effect | na | na | absence of effect | na | absence of effect |
PM46 | effect ≥ CES | ≥ CES (>) | < CES (<) | ≥ CES (>) | < CES (<) | < CES (<) | confirmed ≥ CES |
PM47 | effect ≥ CES | absence of effect | absence of effect | absence of effect | effect of unknown magnitude (<) | ≥ CES (<) | effect ≥ CES |
PM48 | effect ≥ CES | < CES (<) | < CES (<) | absence of effect | ≥ CES (<) | absence of effect | effect ≥ CES |
PM49 | effect ≥ CES | ≥ CES (>) | effect of unknown magnitude (>) | effect of unknown magnitude (>) | ≥ CES (>) | < CES (<) | effect ≥ CES |
PM50 | effect ≥ CES | absence of effect | < CES (<) | < CES (<) | < CES (>) | ≥ CES (>) | effect ≥ CES |
PM51 | effect < CES | absence of effect | na | < CES (<) | absence of effect | absence of effect | effect < CES |
PM52 | no result: study not required | no result: study not required | no result: study not required | no result: study not required | no result: study not required | no result: study not required | absence of effect |
PM53 | effect ≥ CES | absence of effect | ≥ CES (<) | effect of unknown magnitude (>) | < CES (>) | < CES (>) | effect ≥ CES |
Highest Level of Effect for Fish | Survival | Growth | Reproduction | Body Condition | Liver Condition | Highest Level of Effect for Fish and Fish Habitat | |
U1 | confirmed variable magnitude | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed variable magnitude (<) | confirmed < CES (<) | confirmed ≥ CES |
U2 | confirmed ≥ CES | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES (>) | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES (<) | confirmed ≥ CES |
U3 | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES |
U4 | confirmed ≥ CES | unconfirmed effect | confirmed unknown magnitude (>) | unconfirmed effect | confirmed variable magnitude (>) | na | confirmed ≥ CES |
U5 | confirmed ≥ CES | confirmed absence of effect | confirmed ≥ CES (>) | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES (>) | confirmed ≥ CES |
U6 | effect of unknown magnitude | effect of unknown magnitude (<) | effect of unknown magnitude (<) | effect of unknown magnitude (>) | effect of unknown magnitude (<) | absence of effect | effect ≥ CES |
Highest Level of Effect for Fish | Survival | Growth | Reproduction | Body Condition | Liver Condition | Highest Level of Effect for Fish and Fish Habitat | |
O1 | confirmed absence of effect | na | na | na | confirmed absence of effect | na | confirmed ≥ CES |
O2 | effect of unknown magnitude | effect of unknown magnitude (>) | effect of unknown magnitude (>) | na | absence of effect | na | unconfirmed effect |
O3 | confirmed variable magnitude | confirmed variable magnitude (<) | unconfirmed effect | confirmed < CES (>) | unconfirmed effect | unconfirmed effect | confirmed ≥ CES |
O4 | no result: study not required | no result: study not required | no result: study not required | no result: study not required | no result: study not required | no result: study not required | confirmed ≥ CES |
- Date modified: